Artisanal Homemade Peanut Butter – Smithville and Cape May Peanut Butter Companies

If you LOVE peanut butter the Cape May and Smithville locations are “must visit” destinations. 

The first thing that hits you is the great smell of freshly baked cookies and scones and the sight of abundantly stocked bakery cases featuring peanut butter themed treats, sandwiches and more! A wide variety of nut butters, peanut butter accompaniments, candies and gifts fill the shelves of our quaint friendly shops.

All our nut butters are freshly batched and ground in house – and featured flavors expand way beyond your traditional peanut butter. Butterscotch, Chocolate and Cappucino are only a sample of the peanut butters you will find fully stocked.  Interested in trying something new? We also offer alternative nut/seed butters such as Almond, Cashew and Sunflower.  And keep your eyes peeled for our limited edition small-batch peanut butter flavors, they are sure to amaze.  

Don’t worry if you run out or aren’t able to visit in person you can find all of your favorite items and stay up to date on new releases by visiting our online store!